Expiration & Storage Tips
When does cookie dough ice cream expire?
Commercially prepared cookie dough ice cream will typically have a 'best by' or 'sell by' date printed on its packaging. This can range anywhere from two to four months from the production date, depending on the brand and type of ice cream. However, even after this date, the ice cream will be safe to eat for several months if stored properly in the freezer, though its quality may degrade over time. Once opened, it's best to consume the ice cream within two weeks for the best taste and texture. Freezing homemade cookie dough ice cream—which is less common, but still doable—can extend its life up to three months, as long as it’s stored in an airtight container.
How do you tell if cookie dough ice cream is bad?
Determining if your cookie dough ice cream has gone bad isn't difficult. Firstly, letting ice cream thaw and refreeze multiple times can cause it to develop ice crystals or get a grainy texture. A strong or unusual smell might also signal that the ice cream has spoiled. Off-color might suggest freezer burn or spoilage. And certainly, if you see any signs of mold (which is extremely rare but possible), it means the ice cream is not good to eat. Taste can be a final indicator; if it tastes off or sour, it's time to toss the tub.
Tips for storing cookie dough ice cream to extend shelf life
• Always store your ice cream at a consistent and cold temperature, ideally at -20°F (-6°C) or colder. This prevents it from thawing and refreezing, ensuring a consistent texture.
• Avoid storing ice cream near the freezer door where temperature fluctuation is more likely.
• Always ensure that the container is tightly sealed, to preserve its taste and texture and to keep out odors from other items in the freezer.
• If you've scooped some ice cream out, place a piece of plastic wrap directly on the remaining ice cream before replacing the lid. This can help prevent crystallization and freezer burn.